Memorial Church
Cambridge, Massachusetts
September 17, 2002
I speak with you today not as President of the
University but as a concerned member of our community
about something that I never thought I would become
seriously worried about -- the issue of anti-Semitism.
I am Jewish, identified but hardly devout. In my
lifetime, anti-Semitism has been remote from my
experience. My family all left Europe at the beginning
of the 20th century. The Holocaust is for me a matter
of history, not personal memory. To be sure, there
were country clubs where I grew up that had few if any
Jewish members, but not ones that included people I
knew. My experience in college and graduate school, as
a faculty member, as a government official -- all
involved little notice of my religion.
Indeed, I was struck during my years in the Clinton
administration that the existence of an economic
leadership team with people like Robert Rubin, Alan
Greenspan, Charlene Barshefsky and many others that
was very heavily Jewish passed without comment or
notice -- it was something that would have been
inconceivable a generation or two ago, as indeed it
would have been inconceivable a generation or two ago
that Harvard could have a Jewish President.
Without thinking about it much, I attributed all of
this to progress -- to an ascendancy of enlightenment
and tolerance. A view that prejudice is increasingly
put aside. A view that while the politics of the
Middle East was enormously complex, and contentious,
the question of the right of a Jewish state to exist
had been settled in the affirmative by the world
community.
But today, I am less complacent. Less complacent and
comfortable because there is disturbing evidence of an
upturn in anti-Semitism globally, and also because of
some developments closer to home.
Consider some of the global events of the last year:
There have been synagogue burnings, physical assaults
on Jews, or the painting of swastikas on Jewish
memorials in every country in Europe. Observers in
many countries have pointed to the worst outbreak of
attacks against the Jews since the Second World War.
Candidates who denied the significance of the
Holocaust reached the runoff stage of elections for
the nation?s highest office in France and Denmark.
State-sponsored television stations in many nations of
the world spew anti-Zionist propaganda.
The United Nations-sponsored World Conference on
Racism -- while failing to mention human rights abuses
in China, Rwanda, or anyplace in the Arab world --
spoke of Israel?s policies prior to recent struggles
under the Barak government as constituting ethnic
cleansing and crimes against humanity. The NGO
declaration at the same conference was even more
virulent.
I could go on. But I want to bring this closer to
home. Of course academic communities should be and
always will be places that allow any viewpoint to be
expressed. And certainly there is much to be debated
about the Middle East and much in Israel?s foreign and
defense policy that can be and should be vigorously
challenged.
But where anti-Semitism and views that are profoundly
anti-Israeli have traditionally been the primary
preserve of poorly educated right-wing populists,
profoundly anti-Israel views are increasingly finding
support in progressive intellectual communities.
Serious and thoughtful people are advocating and
taking actions that are anti-Semitic in their effect
if not their intent.
For example:
Hundreds of European academics have called for an end
to support for Israeli researchers, though not for an
end to support for researchers from any other nation.
Israeli scholars this past spring were forced off the
board of an international literature journal.
At the same rallies where protesters, many of them
university students, condemn the IMF and global
capitalism and raise questions about globalization, it
is becoming increasingly common to also lash out at
Israel. Indeed, at the anti-IMF rallies last spring,
chants were heard equating Hitler and Sharon.
Events to raise funds for organizations of
questionable political provenance that in some cases
were later found to support terrorism have been held
by student organizations on this and other campuses
with at least modest success and very little
criticism.
And some here at Harvard and some at universities
across the country have called for the University to
single out Israel among all nations as the lone
country where it is inappropriate for any part of the
university?s endowment to be invested. I hasten to say
the University has categorically rejected this
suggestion.
We should always respect the academic freedom of
everyone to take any position. We should also recall
that academic freedom does not include freedom from
criticism. The only antidote to dangerous ideas is
strong alternatives vigorously advocated.
I have always throughout my life been put off by those
who heard the sound of breaking glass, in every insult
or slight, and conjured up images of Hitler?s
Kristallnacht at any disagreement with Israel. Such
views have always seemed to me alarmist if not
slightly hysterical. But I have to say that while they
still seem to me unwarranted, they seem rather less
alarmist in the world of today than they did a year
ago.
I would like nothing more than to be wrong. It is my
greatest hope and prayer that the idea of a rise of
anti-Semitism proves to be a self-denying prophecy --
a prediction that carries the seeds of its own
falsification. But this depends on all of us.
Russian versia



